About the College of Reviewers

The College of Reviewers is a member-focused resource designed to professionalize peer review, enhance review quality, and provide a more stable base of experienced reviewers for all funding competitions.

The College is guided by the work of ten College Chairs, and is centred on the core functions of:

  • Building capacity to ensure that appropriate expertise is available to support peer review efforts for varied programs and activities that span the full spectrum of Canadian health research;
  • Working with the research community to advance equity, diversity, and inclusion practices in peer review processes, including committee recruitment College member recruitment;
  • Providing learning and mentoring opportunities to sharpen College members’ skills;
  • Enhancing review quality assurance practices in peer review; and
  • Managing and supporting the College membership base with appropriate incentives and recognition efforts.

Since its first wave of enrolment in June 2017, the College of Reviewers has grown to approximately 4,500 membersFootnote 1 that have made a commitment to help meet the peer review needs of CIHR’s funding competitions.

Member Demographics

The College’s initial enrolment efforts began by seeking out the recruitment of Full Members that met all of the College’s Membership Selection Criteria. In early 2018, the College was pleased to announce the Associate Member Program as an opportunity to bring researchers into the College who did not yet meet all of the Membership Selection Criteria (for Academics), particularly those in the early stages of their careers.

Moving forward, the College aims to ensure balanced representation within its membership. As part of our targeted recruitment efforts, we will continuously monitor the membership base to fill expertise and demographic gaps in alignment with CIHR's Equity Strategy and competition reviewing needs. To help with this the College is pleased to announce the Reviewer Pathway, which is a comprehensive suite of learning and capacity development programs aimed at supporting the development of peer review skills across career stages, expertise and background, such as patients and knowledge users.

For questions about the following data and/or the College’s overall membership demographics, please contact college@cihr-irsc.gc.ca. The following demographic information is based on self-reported data from College Members.

College Membership by Type

As of August 30, 2019 the College’s Membership base is composed of:
4,515 Full Members

38 Associate Members

10 College Chairs

College Membership by Primary Theme

College Membership by Primary Theme – as of August 30, 2019
Theme College Members % of Membership Base
Biomedical (Theme 1) 2,451 54%
Clinical (Theme 2) 796 17%
Health Systems/Services (Theme 3) 412 9%
Social/Cultural/Environmental/Population Health (Theme 4) 603 13%
UncategorizedFootnote 2 301 7%
Total 4,563 100%

College Membership by Sex

College Membership by Sex – as of August 30, 2019
Sex College Members % of Membership Base
Female 1,755 38%
Male 2,808 62%
Total 4,563 100%

College Members by Geographic Distribution

College Members by Geographic DistributionFootnote 3 – as of August 30, 2019
Province College Members % of Membership Base
British Columbia 535 11.72%
Alberta 527 11.55%
Saskatchewan 92 2.02%
Manitoba 140 3.07%
Ontario 1,743 38.20%
Quebec 1,112 24.37%
New Brunswick 17 0.37%
Nova Scotia 129 2.83%
Prince Edward Island 2 0.04%
Newfoundland and Labrador 43 0.94%
Northwest Territories 1 0.02%
Other - International 222 4.87%
Total 4,563 100%
Date modified: